SBI Live Q&A

Your October Questions Answered (Part Five)

Geoff Cameron (ISIphotos.com)

Photo by ISIphotos.com

Good evening folks. Hope you enjoyed your Thanksgiving festivities. We took it easy on the posting front today as we enjoyed the holiday with our families and friends, but I couldn't let the day go by without at least some reading material.

The most recent Q&A took place on Monday, but with so many good questions still remaining from the October Q&A, I decided to work on answering some more of those before moving on to the November questions.

Here is Part Five of Your October Questions Answered:

DBEX SAID– 1. Leaving aside Castillo and Jones, what non-capped players would you like to see getting a look in the next few months?

2. What question do you get repeatedly asked in these Q&A sessions that drives you the craziest?😉

IVES– 1. Geoff Cameron, Marcus Tracy and Alejandro Bedoya are three uncapped players who who come to mind as players I'd like to see called up in the coming months. With central defense, forward and wing positions all needing some depth, I can see each of these players getting serious looks in 2010.

2. Questions about the starting lineup for the USA at the World Cup can be annoying since its so far away, while promotion/relegation questions can be pointless considering how many times they've been asked. Questions about Freddy Adu and why he should be playing for the national team have become pretty pointless as well.


SETH– what's happening with richie williams in ny? does he get his shot or what?

IVES– Williams is in limbo right now, serving as the Red Bulls interim head coach, but if I were a betting man I’d bet he isn’t being hired by New York (which is a joke in my book). If that’s the case, then I would imagine he lands with one of the other openings around the league, with D.C. being the most logical choice.


CHRIS A– What happened to Special 1 TV?

IVES– Setanta’s financial meltdown happened.


WONSAN UNITED– Why don't more American players go down to Mexico?

IVES– That’s a good question. I think a fair number of Americans go down, they just happen to be Mexican-Americans. The days of folks like Mike Sorber and Christopher Sullivan heading down to Mexico seem long gone and it’s probably due to the money Americans can find in smaller European leagues as well as the presence of MLS, where good American players can make good money.

I also think there’s an issue of style of play and how many Americans are really adept at playing the technical style that is played in Mexico. Obviously Landon Donovan is someone who can go down and play in Mexico, and I’m sure there are plenty of others who could as well, but the players who could go there and do well are already playing and earning good livings in MLS.


TONY T– FC Dallas FAN situation, The main reason I didn't get season tickets this year is because of the drive, they are around 30 miles away from Dallas. Do you think moving them back to the Cotton Bowl would draw more fans? I can see that they have invested too much in Frisco for that to happen but I don't think the 10,000(give or take) fans per game is paying the bills.

IVES– I’m really starting to wonder whether MLS is thinking long and hard about what to do with Pizza Hut Park. MLS commissioner Don Garber mentioned on multiple occasions the problem FC Dallas has with being so far from Dallas. I don’t think you’ll see FC Dallas leaving Pizza Hut Park any time soon, but if some semi-pro football team came along and offered good money for the stadium, something tells me FC Dallas would jump at the offer.


DAVID– Who's the next head coach of the Wizards? Are NYRB going to try and pry Vermes back home to Jersey as their technical director?

IVES– This obviously didn’t happen, which is unfortunate for New York. Vermes is now the Wizards head coach, but I have a feeling he’ll move out of that role sooner than later, as soon as he finds a head coach he’s comfortable handing the reins to. As for New York, they’ve already hired Norwegian Erik Soler to be the team’s general manager. His lack of experience with MLS and American soccer in general is frightening and Red Bulls fans had better pray the team hires a coach with MLS experience. Otherwise, the team is going to be an absolute disaster (again).


TEN-FOUR SAID– What's a realistic, good group draw for the US look like?

IVES– I did a mock draw last week and thought that a draw of Spain, Greece and Uruguay wasn’t the worst possible draw. Obviously in an ideal world the U.S. ends up in South Africa’s group, but saving that, the Americans will want to avoid the Netherlands or Portugal out of the Europeans Only pot (or France or whatever other fringe seeded team that doesn’t get a seed) as well as avoiding Ivory Coast and Paraguay from the African/South America pot (ideally the Americans land Algeria or Uruguay from that pot, but even those teams won’t really be pushovers).

The dream draw? South Africa, Switzerland and Algeria. If the USA scores that group, Sunil Gulati might start break dancing at the draw.


TR– After seeing some of the young talent in the WC qualifiers – Bryan Ruiz, Carlos Costly, etc – who are playing in "lesser" leagues in Europe like Holland or Poland (although Costly is on loan to Birmingham I guess) – is there any chance MLS can pry some of these young Central American potential stars away from Europe?

IVES– Holland’s a lesser league? Lesser than what, the EPL? Ruiz plays for FC Twente, the top team in the Dutch League and a Europa League participant. Costly moved to Poland on a big transfer deal. Until MLS gets into the business of spending money to buy players AND pay them the money they need to come, you won’t see those kind of young studs coming to MLS. I actually heard that Toronto FC inquired about Costly before he moved to Europe but his price tag was too high.

The harsh reality is the days of the Central American bargains are over. Now that players such as Wilson Palacios, Maynor Figueroa, Hendry Thomas and Ruiz are starring in Europe, scouts from across the pond are starting to spend real money in Central America, which has teams down there wanting more and more for their top prospects.


TICKLE ME FUNNY– What is your personal contingency plan in the event of a zombie apocalypse?

IVES– Having seen enough zombie movies for an all-day marathon, I’ve found that weapons, food and a big building you know your way around are key to at least surviving the initial onslaught. From there, you need to be able to secure a vehicle to get around (now if we’re talking night-time only zombies, ala I Am Legend, then you can travel quite a ways during that first daylight). I’d make my way to the shore and try to stock a boat and hit the ocean (I’ve never seen zombies be able to swim so I think I’d be safe on the water). And yes, I realize the question and my answer were absurd, but so what?


DANNY– Ives what's your view on young American players going to Europe?…It seems like the young guns are making the switch way to soon now a days, and really are damaging their career…Wouldn't you rather see them play in MLS then sit on the bench in Europe?

IVES– Yes, I absolutely agree that too many are simply taking the money and jumping into bad situations. That being said, the fact that MLS doesn’t have a reserve league makes it that much tougher for young prospects to consider MLS, with the logic being if you’re going to go somewhere to not play, it may as well be where they’re going to pay you very well. If MLS expands rosters and brings back the reserve league, then I absolutely feel that young American players will need to start considering MLS over the bigger payday of Europe.


WESTENDFC-Will there ever be a Team America in Europe like there was going be in Bari and will it be successful? I am not counting that team in the Belgian Fourth Division, Montegnee.

IVES– I don’t think we’ll ever realistically see that. Could we wind up having a team that imports two or three Americans and give us something like we saw at Fulham from 07/08? That is possible, but a team loaded with Americans? Never going to happen in Europe (and not just because many leagues have limits on foreign players.)


SHAWN SAID– I would like your opinion on something I've noticed about Jozy Altidore. It seems that during most of his goal celebrations of late he has been inclined to focus more on his name on the back of his shirt. I thought the golden rule was that the name on the front of a jersey is much more important than the name on the back. I only ask, because during the national anthem he stands, although respectfully, without his Hand over his heart. I know I'm being a bit nit-picky, but is there some message he's trying to send? Jozy is a gift and we're lucky to have him. I just hope he understands the huge honor of playing for a national team.

IVES– I think you’re making WAY too much out of nothing at all. Let me ask you this. If you were a 19-year-old kid scoring national team goals I’m pretty sure you’d be pulling off some outlandish goal-scoring celebrations. I know I would.


SHANTZ– will EJ make the world cup team

IVES– Maybe. I’d give Eddie Johnson a 30 percent chance of making it right now, but that number won’t go up unless Johnson finds a way to score some playing time next year.


STEVE Y– How important is having a European passport to having a young US prospect sign with a European team? It seems like most of the prospect-level signings (e.g., Szetela, Arnoux) have been for Americans with access to a EU passport. If visa restrictions were lifted, would a LOT more American prospects find their way onto European squads?

IVES– If Americans didn’t need passports or visa eligibility to play in many European leagues, there would be countless Americans making the jump and MLS would be in serious trouble because it would have to increase salaries significantly to compete. Luckily for MLS, that isn’t the case.


BECKER– How long will it be before we have a young promising talent in the midfield like we have in jozy?….. i'd die to have some 17 year old come up and tear up mls and make it to europe.

IVES– It’s going to be a few years before we see a teenage midfielder come into MLS and be an impact player. The last teenage midfielder I can recall having any sort of effect on the league was Michael Bradley as a 17-year-old starter for the MetroStars in 2005, and Eddie Gaven before that. MLS is just a tough and physical league that isn’t easy for a young midfielder to do well in. That being said, Luis Gil is a special talent, and if he signs with MLS, and the league brings back the reserve league, he might be able to develop and be an impact player in a few years time. I thought Charlie Renken could be that kind of player as well, but injuries have slowed him down and now he’s signed with Hoffenheim.


SOME DUDE IN NYC– Hey ives how do you see the teams from concacaf(costa rica included if they qualify)performing at the world cup. Do you see one or all three/four teams getting out of the first round?

IVES– It all depends on the groups they fall in, but I can see all three CONCACAF teams reaching the second round given the right circumstances. Honduras is a strong team that could be one of the World Cup’s surprises, and Mexico and the USA are strong enough to reach the second round.


DC JOSH– The World Cup is supposed to include the best teams in the world. Unfortunately, some teams don't make it even though they are better than other teams that do (Croatia & North Korea for example). UEFA is loaded with talented teams and could use a couple more World Cup spots while other federations could lose some spots.

Do you think A: something needs to be done about this. B: FIFA will do something about this.

Also, did you travel to RFK? How much did you love the MAGNIFICENT amenities it offers???? I've often heard it compared to the Palace of Versailles.

IVES– A-No and B-No. The World Cup should be representative of the world and I don’t think there’s anything wrong with teams from weaker regions qualifying while some teams from stronger regions don’t. If you can’t crack the Top 14 in Europe then you don’t make the World Cup. It’s that simple. There’s always the European Championships.

As for RFK, I’ve been to RFK something like 30 times in my career covering the game and I love making that trip. The games are always fun and the fans are always great.


GHOST OF CLINT DEMPSEY– What US player(s) do you think is headed to Europe next and at what level of team? I'm thinking Holden and Torres but I am not sure if and when it will happen. When is the question I think.

IVES– I’d say Ricardo Clark and Stuart Holden are safe bets to make the move to Europe, with Jonathan Bornstein also likely to head over. They should all move to Europe in January.


GABE– In your opinion, how much sense would it make to have Freddy Adu switch to striker. No, he's not big and fast…but he definitely seems like a Charlie Davies' type. What's holding back this move?

IVES– He’s not big and fast but he’s like Charlie Davies? Before his injuries, Davies combined blazing speed with uncanny strength and a nose for goal. Adu is neither fast or strong, at least not anywhere near enough to ever be a forward on the international level.


TED– What are the chances Bobby Boswell and Geoff Cameron get a look in the camps leading up to the world cup? With the US teams' new found problem with depth in the center of the defense, having two big guys who are used to playing together wouldn't be such a bad thing. Did Boswell get any serious attention before his dip in form with DC United?

IVES– Boswell is a very good MLS player, but he’s lacking in the speed department for the international game. I think that will always keep him from being a real option for the national team. Cameron is another story. He’s got the type of physical tools that scouts drool over, but he’s not a natural defender and is still learning the position (which is scary considering how well he did in central defense this year).


  • ryan

    agreed this is horrible im ready to jump out a window

    (SBI-What is this, Broncos vs. Giants: Your Running Commentary? LOL.)


  • Leon

    Ives, what’s your take on the NASL(TOA)/USL situation? Does it make sense to have an owner-driven league at the second-tier when it hasn’t gotten off the ground yet in MLS?


  • Sean M

    “The dream draw? South Africa, Switzerland and Algeria. If the USA scores that group, Sunil Gulati might start break dancing at the draw.”

    hahaha that just made my night.Can’t wait till the draw.


  • Isaac

    TOUCHDOWN!!!!BRONCOS!!! What a through ba- I mean…throw…..yeah…..and excellent stepo- I mean studder steps from….ok whatever…


  • Topher

    Can Algeria get drawn in South Africa’s group? Thought you weren’t allowed to have two teams from the same continent (not named Europe).


  • DaveW

    Re:Americans not in Mexico.
    The Primera only allows 5 foreigners per team and a lot of Mexican fans and owners think that’s too many, so a US player without Mexican ties could take a lot of heat.
    Also, it seems as likely or more likely to get to Europe from MLS as from Mexico.
    By the way, Alain N’Kong went from MLS to Atlante and was a contributor in their title run Apertura 2007.
    Finally, much as we US fans criticize USSF, FMF has some serious problems with owners meddling in a really bad way, both in the Primera and with the Mexican national team.(Cf Vergara’s asking for a transfer fee for Omar Bravo when in fact the player’s contract was owned by Deportivo la Coruña.)


  • Greg S

    In response to Shawn’s question concerning jozy altidore:

    No where in American founding literature is any reference to a specific motion for the national anthem outlined (hand over the heart). It’s something that at worst has been confused via ignorance with the pledge of allegiance and at best evolved from that tradition. That said, I do agree with the idea that the young’uns hot dog themselves too much.


  • attenborough

    Diggin’ the Geoff Cameron love. If I could be an MLS manager I’d try to steal him away from Houston with every resource I had (mostly US dollars, probably). I really enjoy watching that self-assured style of play that guys like him, Beckerman and Joseph exhibit carrying a ball through the center of the field. Is it experience alone that’s keeping him behind guys like Marshall for center-back caps?


  • Chris


    You keep saying “if MLS brings back the reserve league” is this something you’ve heard about, or are you just saying it needs to come back? I agree that it needs to come back.


  • someone else

    two words Ives… zombie sharks…

    (SBI-Hey, I said I’d get a boat. Didn’t say I’d go swimming. Guess I’d need a bigger boat.)


  • Arcticrules

    Not sure why you think South Africa would be such a great draw. They are no more a pushover than S. Korea on 2002 which showed that a relatively lesser home team can make it to the 2nd round.

    (SBI-Sorry to tell you, but trying to compare the current South Africa squad to the 2002 South Korea squad is nuts. The South African team is a mess while South Korea was a quality team with an amazing head coach.)


  • RS

    Out of all the teams in Pot 1 (Brazil, Spain, Italy, Germany, Argentina, France, England & South Africa) it seems South Africa would be the best draw of the lot. Would there be another team from this pot you’d rather play instead?


  • Chicago Mike

    World Rankings ; 2nd, 1st, 4th, 6th, 8th, 7th, 9th, 74th respectively. I would say South Africa seems like the one I’d hope for, however, we are 1 and 0 against Spain this year🙂

    (SBI-USA also beat South Africa the last time the teams met in South Africa. There would probably be a few more people at the World Cup rematch, but still.)


  • SrySnffy

    Obviously, everyone hopes for South Africa, but outside of that, i’d hope we draw Germany, maybe Italy. The nats can hang with their styles, if they bring their a game (and Gooch is fit).


  • Beckster

    Ives, re: your Holden answer. Did you see the BBC gossip column this morning about Aberdeen saying that Holden was to expensive for them? Are there other European options or was this the primary one?


  • Austin

    “IVES- Holland’s a lesser league? Lesser than what, the EPL? Ruiz plays for FC Twente, the top team in the Dutch League and a Europa League participant. Costly moved to Poland on a big transfer deal. Until MLS gets into the business of spending money to buy players AND pay them the money they need to come, you won’t see those kind of young studs coming to MLS. I actually heard that Toronto FC inquired about Costly before he moved to Europe but his price tag was too high.”

    Ives, You would actually be surprised to know that Carlos Costly’s contract with i believe Belchatow is up in 2010. MLS could try to get him on a free transfer. He would be a max salary. He has expressed interest in returning to North, Central, or South America as well. With the room Seattle has after Le Toux, Brown, Neagle, and Fucito are all gone, i believe he could be an ideal player.

    Bryan Ruiz would be a DP probably though and Eridivisie is a very good league like Ives mentioned.


  • Matt

    I think it’s funny that you would consider the idea of hiring guys like Peter Vermes or Curt Onalfo to be a good move for NYRB. They have failed at doing much of anything in Kansas City, but the fact that hey have “MLS experience” somehow makes up for it?!

    Personally, I’m tired of seeing the same list of coaches recycled for every team in the league. If Solér sticks with Williams then great. If he feels like he wants to have his own guy in there then I’m OK with that too. At least we won’t have the GM and manager butting heads like we had with Agoos and Osorio.


  • Smith

    I don’t see how hiring someone with MLS experience is a MUST for RBNY. Agoos & the Legendary JCO had plenty of MLS experience & they were a disaster. JCO might be the worst tactical coach in professional sports history. He is the Rich Kotite og futbol. If Stoler hires a foreign coach, so what? As long as has someone on staff with MLS exeprience, it’s fine and that person is Chris DaSilva. Would I rather have Richie Williams? Sure. Would I reather have experienecd MLS vets like Goose & JCO? No. In fact, I’d rather have rabies than have JCO aka Mr. “I will keep playing a 4-5-1 even though we haven’t won with it in ages. ” Let’s be realistic…having MLS experience is not a guarantee of success. And no, guiding a sub-.500 team to a final only to follow it with a compltete disaster of a season does not qulify as success.

    (SBI-William, I’m fully aware of your disdain for Osorio but last time I checked Rich Kotite never got to the Super Bowl, or even won in the playoffs once (let alone twice). Being a coach with MLS experience doesn’t guarantee success, but being a foreign coach with no MLS ties does guarantee that you don’t win. At least that’s the track record throughout the league.

    If you don’t think that having a GM AND a head coach without MLS experience isn’t a recipe for disaster, then please don’t complain when 2010 isn’t much better than 2009 in Red Bulls land.)


  • OmarVizquel

    Just read some Scottish paper rumors about Holden going to Rangers. Hmm, not sure what to make of this.


  • Isaac

    I’m sure I speak for at least half of the SBI Mafia when I say:

    Who the f*** is Devann Yao?


  • OmarVizquel

    I said the same thing to myself. Apparently he was born to immigrants in NYC, “discovered” at 10 or 11, went to some intensive soccer academy in PA, then either trialled or signed with various clubs in Scotland and Italy, but left or was forced to leave for perceived “attitude” issues (according the the clubs).

    6’0” winger.


  • Keith G.

    With the NASL looking to be coming around, do you think they have what it takes to stick around like the MLS has? Also with two of the teams in the NASL already looking to be joining the MLS, do see any chance of them joining up with the MLS, if they have financial problems. I am not saying there will be a relegation format installed, but for now a system like the MLB where the NASL teams are the minor league teams of the MLS?


  • JM

    Why doesn’t FC Dallas lay grass on Gerald J Ford Stadium (32,000) and play on SMU’s campus? Nicest part of the Metroplex, in Dallas, big club soccer particpation in the immediate area…


  • HM

    I seriously think it is time to end the Jozy Altidore hysteria. The kid has scored 1 goal in 18 months on the club level, and that included a lengthy stint in Spain’s second division.

    I understand his physical attributes, but the kid has not proved on the field that he is worthy of all the praise. Strikers must score, and Altidore is working on a goal per 17 matches strike rate. That’s just not good enough.


  • drew in tamp

    HM needs to get the facts straight. Jozy scored for his Spanish club and has scored for Hull. How can you not include his goals for the Nats? Folks like you keep looking for the next big thing without learning to appreciate the talent that’s on the field. Jozy is 19. He is so far ahead of where most of our talents were at his age it’s amazing. I say enjoy the ride. If at 25 we see no promise then it’s ok to begin calling him a bust. Until then, get your facts straight.


  • r.benjamin

    Agreed.. but not. He is once again the best US forward prospect so rooting for him and getting excited about his prospects is what we got.

    Plus his recent form of the past week is finally what we were hoping/expecting in September if not last year.


  • brian

    I think it’s funny, especially after the ’98 and ’06 debacles, that anyone assumes a group with South Africa (host!), Switzerland and Algeria would be easy for the USA. Or any other three teams. Algeria just eliminated the African champion. Switzerland made it out of EUROPE.

    FIFA has set it up so that the USA can make it to every World Cup. There’s too much $ in the American market for that not to happen. But while I’m happy if we advance, I’m also not surprised if we don’t win a game.

    (SBI- Brian, nobody said easy, but it would certainly be the easiest possible group. USA has beaten South Africa in South Africa and the hosts are in a mess right now, the USA has also beaten Switzerland in Switzerland recent. The USA has also beaten the same Egypt team that Algeria struggled to knock off. Not sure why it’s such a crime to think that this group wouldn’t be the easiest of all scenarios. There’s no such thing as easy for any US team in the World Cup, but THAT group would be about as easy as the USA could hope for.)


  • Mike Caramba


    Would you object to me taking your swimming zombies idea and running with it? I really think you’re on to something.


  • jloome

    Geoff Cameron is going to be one of the biggest players in U.S. team history. His potential is that high. Seriously, I wouldn’t be surprised to see him at a premiership or serie a team in the next two years.


  • d-bar

    The problem isn’t even comparing SA to ROK, which doesn’t matter. Which of the top 7 teams in the world would you rather draw instead of South Africa?


  • d-bar

    I’m not sure I’m onboard with the boat idea. It is wonderful while you are onboard, I would be afraid of the logistics of coming back to shore for food and fuel (I guess a sailboat and fishing equipment would be an option). As much as I love being on the water, I think I would go for locking myself in a SuperWalmart (guns, supermarket and cooking equipment). Things to ponder…



    Ives, could you give us an update on Charlie Davies. Haven’t heard anything about him since he was released from the hospital. Is he walking, talking, in for more surgeries or all done? Also, with Clint Dempsey continually showing better form in front of the net as opposed to a frustrating mid, why don’t we start him up top with Jozy & bring Robbie Findley or Jeff Cunningham in as a 65-75th minute super sub.




    Eric Wynalda & Zigi Schmid fill out the bench for the USMNT after this run through the world cup. Unless Bob & the boys replicate 2002 or better.

    Any way this happens Ives (Or anything like it including the fiery Wynalda & the architect Schmid)


  • BigBlueNation

    How have the American boys at Everton been fairing? It’s not something you hear much about.


Add your comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More from SBI Soccer


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,182 other followers