MLS- San Jose Earthquakes

Birchall, Cháves and Yallop disciplined by MLS

Birchall - Getty


Much scrutiny has been made of the disciplinary action taken by the MLS this season.

The latest actions taken see suspensions for LA's Chris Birchall and Chicago's Diego Cháves while San Joe head coach Frank Yallop gets a $500 slap on the wrist for "conduct unbecoming of a professional" during the Earthquakes match against the Union over the weekend. 

Birchall will serve a two-game suspension for his fierce tackle on Patrick Nyarko in the dying minutes of the Galaxy/Fire match.  The ban means that the midfielder will miss Los Angeles's fixture against Columbus on the 20th and the Vancouver Whitecaps 10 days later.  Birchall will also have to fork over $500 for "showing utter disregard for an opponents safety."  He was given a yellow card for his tackle.

Perhaps Birchall's tackle was inspired by the Fire's Cháves who, minutes earlier, roughly took down Landon Donovan, resulting in a yellow card for the striker.  But that wasn't deemed enough for Cháves, who today received a one-game ban and a $250 fine for "endangering the safety of his opponent."  The suspension means that the player will miss the Fire's upcoming match against the Portland Timbers on Saturday.

Frank Yallop was also dished out punishment for being sent off from the sideline by the referee in San Jose's match against Philadelphia.  He was ordered to hand over $500 by the MLS Disciplinary Committee, and that fine, on top of the sending off fine, brings Yallop's total to $1000.  The dismissal from the game means that the head coach will not be allowed to be on the sideline or in any sort of communication with the Earthquakes' bench for the upcoming clash with the Columbus Crew.


What do you think of the latest disciplinary actions?  Are these justified punishments?

Share your thoughts below…

  • Galaxy

    It was a stupid, unnecessary tackle. I hate to see Birchall suspended, but the punishment fits the crime.


  • Ron

    Galaxy needs to upgrade this useless hack and stop playing him on the wing. He can’t shoot and is s too slowwwwww.


  • Jonathon

    Both deserved. Too bad they missed Brovsky’s elbow on Jamie Smith in the VAN-COL game, which was missed by the ref and deserved a 1-game suspension.


  • srfinger

    How about the ref in the LA-Chi game? He had a good look at both of those fouls and couldnt pull the trigger.


  • skinnyj

    I’d like to see that official get a suspension as well. What a pansy, he couldnt pull out a red for Birchall on that tackle. Hell, it almost started a brawl between the benches.


  • Allen23

    Good call by MLS on both player suspensions.

    I would like to know why the offical(s) could not be bothered to show a red card at least to Birchall. Not that it mattered, but if that was not a red, then what is?


  • Greg

    Glad to see Birchall suspended, he deserved a red card during the game for that tackle.


  • Brian

    IMO, Chaves’s tackle was worse. Birchall’s was bad but he just mistimed it. Chaves’s didn’t really even try to go for the ball.


Add your comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More from SBI Soccer