U.S. Open Cup: A closer look at the remaining underdogs

US Open Cup logo



The U.S. Open Cup has had its share of surprises this year, but mostly MLS teams remain as the tournament heads into its quarterfinals stage.

Still, there is a trio of underdogs from third division USL Pro that remain. And they are hoping to keep their dreams of lifting the Open Cup trophy alive next Tuesday when they go on the road to take on more talented MLS teams.

The Harrisburg City Islanders, Charlotte Eagles and Dayton Dutch Lions will be aiming to advance to the semifinals next week, but they all have difficult matches ahead of them in order to make that happen. The City Islanders will be visiting affilliate Philadelphia Union at PPL Park, the Eagles will take on Juan Agudelo and Chivas USA at the Home Depot Center, and the Dutch Lions will travel to Livestrong Sporting Park to battle Sporting Kansas City.

None of the USL Pro teams will be expected to come out with a win. But then again, their presence at this point in the tournament is something few could have foreseen when the tournament began.

Here's a closer look at each of the remaining underdogs in the U.S. Open Cup:


The City Islanders are coming off a big victory over the New York Red Bulls, one in which forward Sainey Touray shined in. Touray scored twice in the match (including on the decisive goal early in extra time), but he is hardly the only player to have shined for Harrisburg. Goalkeeper Nick Noble came up with several quality saves to thwart a desperate Red Bulls attack, and the midfield did well to pressure their Red Bulls counterparts.


The Eagles may not have faced an MLS side in the last round, but their 2-1 extra time win over the San Antonio Scorpions marked the second consecutive round in this competition that Charlotte has gone on the road and won. Charlotte has pulled off upsets in the last two rounds with wins over FC Dallas and San Antonio, and head coach Mark Steffens appears to have his team believing in their abilities. On top of that, several players are currently contributing to the team's cause, meaning there is not just one marquee player for opposing teams to focus on.


Of the three USL Pro teams left, the Dayton Dutch Lions had the easiest opponent in the fourth round. But they knocked off the Columbus Crew in the previous round, so they should not be overlooked even though they have yet to win in league play this season. Dayton goalkeeper Matthew Williams is currently in great form, having made crucial saves in the win over the Crew and in Tuesday's 2-1 extra time victory over PDL side Michigan Bucks.


Which underdogs do you think will advance to the semifinals? Who do you see as having the best chance of winning the whole tournament?

Share your thoughts below.

  • Felix

    Wasn’t Nick Noble a backup ‘keeper with the Fire a couple of years ago?


  • Adam

    Dayton must be taking notes from the Toronto playbook: “How to lose a league and win tournaments”


  • Brain Guy

    You got that right. I watched ET. What a terrible non-call. Also, I didn’t see Harrisburg’s first goal, but wasn’t the guy offside?

    RBNY had some chances, but didn’t finish them. Should have won in regulation time.

    Strange how no NASL teams have survived, but three from a lower tier have.


  • David

    It’s hard to believe Dayton actually won. I was at the game against the Bucks and they were played off the park for nearly the entire match. Their goalkeeper made four or five terrific saves, watched one shot come back off the post, and saw at least half a dozen wide open heading opportunities go over the bar. Dayton had about 4 chances all game and got 2 goals. That’s cup football. It’s easy to see how they lose games though. Their luck just happens to have coincided with their Open Cup schedule.


  • Kevin

    as a local, I would like to support the Charlotte Eagles, but they are affiliated with a local Christian School and are owned/operated by a religious organization, which is something I cannot support…

    I do follow their progress but have never attended a match…its nice to see them make a Cup Run, as they typically stink it up every year…


  • NCJoe

    Oh no! A religous cult. Cant support christians,, but assume muslims would be okay?

    Go Charlotte!


Add your comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More from SBI Soccer


A busy week for the USL kicks off Friday night in Kansas City with last year’s western conference champions, Swope Park Rangers, taking on current leaders, San Antonio FC. Reno 1868 FC’s match (…)