Under-20 World Cup

Who Should the U.S. U-20s start against New Zealand?

The U.S. Under-20 Men’s National Team’s draw with Saudi Arabia was enough to push the group into the knockout round, but the result didn’t come without consequence as the Round of 16 looms.

Due to a controversial red card, Cameron Carter-Vickers is set to serve a one-game suspension for Thursday’s Round of 16 clash with New Zealand, depriving the U.S. of a defensive star. Add in yellow card suspensions to Derrick Jones and Aaron Herrera and the U.S. defense and midfield faces a major reshuffle ahead of what will certainly be a difficult match.

Given the trio of suspensions, and injury to Gedion Zelalem, the U.S. is extremely short-handed with just 17 players eligible to dress for the match. Tab Ramos will need to manage some shuffling and some difficult choices as he looks to assemble a team capable of knocking off New Zealand.

With that in mind, here’s a look at a potential lineup Ramos could lean on for Thursday’s match:

Heading into Thursday’s match, Ramos will need to make three key decisions. He’ll need to figure out how to replace the team’s best defender, and, arguably, best player. He’ll need to manage a fullback position that has always been this group’s weakness. And, finally, he’ll need to figure out a midfield that is suddenly very, very thin.

Starting from the back, we can at least all but guarantee Jonathan Klinsmann is safe, but what happens in front of him is anyone’s guess. With Carter-Vickers suspended due to his dubious dismissal, the U.S. is without their backline anchor. Centerback is likely the team’s biggest strength, giving Ramos a few options.

He could continue to roll with Erik Palmer-Brown who has, to his credit, been spectacular. The Sporting KC defender could be paired with either Justen Glad or Tommy Redding, two players plenty capable of stepping in. Or, given the absence of a defensive midfielder like Jones, Ramos could push Palmer-Brown up to  the No. 6 role he played in qualifying, taking advantage of the centerback depth.

Tyler Adams and Eryk Williamson should both be in the lineup, but neither is a pure No. 6. The ramifications of playing without a pure defensive mid were felt early against Ecuador via an early blitz. Jones’ introduction calmed all of that down. He won’t be there on Thursday, but the lessons learned from his early absence should surely be felt. Does it hurt the backline to move Palmer-Brown up? Sure, but it’s better than the alternative of tying one of Adams or Williamson down to a position that doesn’t truly fit them.

Then there’s the fullback position. Without Herrera, the U.S. is missing a starter at a position with virtually no depth. Adams is a player that has played the position, but he’s been too good in a box-to-box role to shift back without major consequences. Ramos could move one of the centerbacks out wide or drop one of the wingers back and hope for the best, but starting Auston Trusty is the best bet as the Philadelphia Union defender goes from injury replacement to Round of 16 starter.

The rest of the lineup is pretty straightforward. No one is taking Josh Sargent’s place atop the field, and the service from Luca de la Torre and Brooks Lennon has been too good to break up that trio. Sebastian Saucedo becomes a valuable bench option if the U.S. is in need of a goal, while Emmauel Sabbi and Jeremy Ebobisse could also be potential forward subs if the U.S. is chasing.

Adams and Williamson remain the midfield stars and the two will need to continue to balance play from their box-to-box roles. Adams has been one of the team’s top players, and he’ll have to have to be on again to help push a shorthanded U.S. team into the quarterfinal round.

  • Gary Page

    Not having seen New Zealand play and knowing nothing about them, it makes it hard to make suggestions here. Nevertheless, Palmer-Brown has been such a rock at CB, I would hesitate to move him.Maybe you move Acosta to defensive mid and then Reddig to one of the FB spots.


  • wychijeff

    I like SBI’s lineup. Pretty similar lineup to what we played in qualifying. We did win the region with it after all so they players are familiar in the system.


  • Benjamin C.

    If the U.S. does advance, the suspensions may be a blessing in disguise, as they will be on two days less rest than Venezuela. Both Jones and CCV, who play physical styles, will be relatively fresh, and Glad and Redding (despite the opener) are capable professionals that can be trusted to fill in against New Zealand. If the game is in hand in the second half, I would definitely consider pulling Sargent as early as possible. He is still very young, despite how great he has been, and has taken a beating over the course of the tourney.


    • LouisZ

      unfortunately, we don’t play with just those 3 players. The rest of the team will be hard pressed to recover quickly for the next game.


      • Benjamin C.

        Very true, the scheduling is brutal in this case for whoever wins. I’m guessing New Zealand will play a physical style against the U.S. as well, which makes it even more of a task going forward.


  • TheFrenchOne

    I assume NZ is dealing with some injuries as well, but don’t know. In every tournament, these kinds of scenarios hit most teams and they have to make due. Here’s to hoping Tab can pull the right levers.


  • Andy in Atlanta

    If we sneak by NZ so shorthanded this tournament is there for the taking… NZ, then Venezuela, then Uru/Port winner.. Final against France, England or Mexico…. easily the simplest road to a title for US Soccer in many many years… not been this confident since 2007 U 20s…


    • Johnnyrazor

      2007 when we lost to Austria in the quarterfinals? That tournament proves the point no path is easy in youth tournaments Venezuela hasn’t given up a goal in four matches and France the tournament favorites haven’t either.


  • Johnnyrazor

    McKennie, Wright, and Taitague won the Westfalen Cup title yesterday behind goals from Nick and Haji. So all is not lost they missed the WC for what would be the equivalent of a State Title.


  • I scored three goals in one game

    Don’t think they should move EPB up, he’s been playing to good in the back and has probably played himself into a summer move. Reading wasn’t very good against Ecuador so just put Glad in CCV’s place. I’m not trying to be hard on Herrera but anybody else at right back would be OK with me. Acosta has been decent at LB so just let Adams and Williamson play little deeper. Lennon on the right, de LA Torre on the left and Sargent up top. Only question is who should play as the 10 or should they play another striker in a 4-4-2.


Add your comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More from SBI Soccer