Top Stories

MLS Ticker: Espindola’s red card appeal denied; Pogatetz convinced by Berhalter; and more

FabianEspindolaDCUnited4-NewYorkRedBulls (USATodaySportsImages)

Photo by Brad Mills/ USA Today Sports



The MLS Disciplinary Committee dished out fines to players on both D.C. United and the New York Red Bulls for their part in a mid-game fracas, but it was one move they didn’t make that is stealing the headlines on Monday evening.

MLS evidently has denied Fabian Espindola’s red card appeal, meaning that the Argentine forward is suspended for D.C. United’s next match, on Saturday at the Chicago Fire. Espindola was sent off in the 32nd minute of D.C. United’s 1-0 defeat to the Red Bulls last Wednesday for a high boot in a challenge with Dax McCarty.

The Disciplinary Committee also fined D.C. United defender Sean Franklin and midfielder Davy Arnaud, as well as Red Bulls defender Roy Miller for their roles in a confrontation that took place in the 38th minute of Wednesday’s matchup. In addition, D.C. United and head coach Ben Olsen were also fined for the incident as a result of the club’s second violation of the mass confrontation policy.  As per league policy, the exact amounts of the fines were undisclosed.

The incident stemmed from a conflict between Miller and D.C. United midfielder Nick DeLeon. After seeing the two exchange words, Franklin intervened, causing a confrontation that soon included Arnaud. Miller shoved and grabbed Arnaud before referee Mark Geiger diffused the situation.

Here are some more of Monday’s news and notes from around MLS:


New Columbus Crew signing Emanuel Pogatetz met with the media for the first time on Monday afternoon and revealed how and why he decided to come stateside.

Pogatetz claimed that after just a few conversations with Crew head coach Gregg Berhalter, he was convinced that it was time to come and join the team right in the middle of the playoff race.

“I had a really good conversation with Gregg Berhalter,” Pogatetz said at the club’s Obetz training ground. “After the first two times we were talking on the phone, I had a really good feeling about coming to this club, that it would be the right choice for me. I think that made the difference in the end, why I decided to come to MLS and especially the Crew.”

Pogatetz also talked about how he hopes to be a “good example” for the younger players on the team, and to use his experience from Europe to help lead the Crew to the playoffs.


The Colorado Rapids are facing an uphill fight in their battle for postseason play, and that climb is set to be made even tougher due to an injury to Vicente Sanchez.

The 34-year-old midfielder is set to miss at least two weeks with a knee sprain, an injury that previously kept the Uruguayan out for seven games in May and June.

“He’s got swelling in his knee; I just got the memo it’ll be 2-3 weeks,” said head coach Pablos Mastroeni. “When he’s ready, he’ll jump in.”

Sanchez has scored six goals in 14 appearances this season, good for second on the team.


With the success of LA Galaxy II, many MLS clubs are looking towards the model of starting up their very own reserve side in the lower divisions. However, the New York Red Bulls have other plans in mind.

Sporting director Andy Roxburgh says that the Red Bulls aren’t interested in putting together a reserve team, as the club will instead look to come to an agreement  with an affiliate side.

“The goal is clearly to have it settled and organized,” Roxburgh said. “We will not have our own team, that much I can tell. We will not have own team.

“We will not be creating our own USL Pro team here. That much I can tell you. We’re in the process of trying to organize our relationship with someone else.”


The Vancouver Whitecaps have gotten a bit younger by signing two of the club’s most prolific youth stars.

The club announced the signings of 18-year-old midfielders Kianz Froese and Marco Bustos Monday, with Froese set to join up with the senior team immediately. Meanwhile, Bustos is expected to join up with the Whitecaps in January.

Froese, who debuted with the first team in a May Canadian Championship clash with Toronto FC, has earned a callup to the Canadian national team and scored four goals in seven matches with the Whitecaps FC U-23 side during 2014 USL PDL season.

“Kianz has a great technical element to his game and an athleticism that will serve him well as he steps up to the next level,” said Whitecaps head coach Carl Robinson. “He’s worked hard to earn this opportunity and we’re excited to see him continue his progression.”

Meanwhile, Bustos, who also featured for the first team in May, was named the Whitecaps FC Most Promising Player in 2013 and appeared in appeared in all three of Canada’s matches in the 2013 U-17 World Cup, starting twice.

“It’s an honor to sign my first professional contract with the club that has supported me and shown belief in me throughout my development,” said Bustos. “I want to thank my family and friends and all the Whitecaps FC coaches and staff who have helped me achieve my dream.”

The additions of Kianz and Bustos bring the club’s total to 11 all-time Homegrown signings.


Earthquakes fans will have one more chance to see their squad take on an international club before the end of the 2014 calendar year.

The Earthquakes announced on Monday that they’ve scheduled a friendly match against C.D. Vida of Honduras, the former club of Earthquakes centerback Victor Bernardez. The match will take place on Oct. 14 at Buck Shaw Stadium. General tickets will go on sale on Wednesday, while a pre-sale is underway for season-ticker holders.

The Earthquakes took on defending La Liga champions Atletico Madrid last July in Candlestick Park in San Francisco, falling, 4-3, on penalty kicks.

What do you think of these notes? Do you feel Espindola should have had his red card rescinded? How much do you see Pogatetz helping the Crew late in the season?

Share your thoughts below.


  1. I’m not sure what was dangerous about that play that it warranted a red card. Espindola did not point his cleats at Dax, Dax simply ran into the side of his (admittedly a bit high) foot. How that’s even a yellow is perplexing. By contrast, Miller tries to choke Arnaud off the ball, and does not get a suspension.

    The MLS moral to young players: If you play hard and focus on the ball you will get suspended. If you try to choke someone off the ball, you won’t. If you run into someone’s foot after they kick the ball and fall to the ground pretending you’ve been shot with a .45, you can get them kicked out

    Nice job Indisciplinary Committee!

      • Mark Geiger and now the MLS Disciplinary Committee disagree with you. You wouldn’t happen to be a DCU fan, now would you?

      • Care to offer your own interpretation or only complaints about bias? Could the DISCO be biased towards protecting the refs rep? Or possibly have very stringent requirements to overturn previous calls?

        My own viewpoint is shared with Dax (guy who drew the red), Twellman, and many others. A high boot with no mal-intent should not be grounds for a red. A high boot with no mal-intent and the ball clearly in the vicinity of the high boot (i.e. an attempt to play the ball) should absolutely not be a red. A yellow or a warning would have sufficed, in my opinion.

      • Well, I expressed my opinion on the prior thread, but I’ll do it again for you. Geiger made a bad call, but blame Espindola for a dumb play that put his fate in the hands of the ref.

      • It’s a judgment call. To me, on TV, it looked like the red was a little harsh. But I can understand the Disciplinary Committee not having enough to overturn the ref’s on field decision.

        To me, what you should be taking from this is that it was a dumb, reckless play by the DCU player, even if maybe it wasn’t a red card offense. Sticking his foot into McCarty’s chest when he saw McCarty coming and knew he had little or no chance to play the ball could very easily be construed as a red card. You put the ref in a position to make significant decisions, sometimes those decisions are going to go against you.

      • thanks for the response.

        to me, the whole point of the appeals process is to remedy those situations where, due to close review of multiple replays, you can say that the punishment was unwarranted (as it was in this case).

        yes, refs make mistakes. but this is supposed to be the way to lessen the negative consequences of those mistakes. i’m not sure if the DC is just deliberately trying to not weaken the referees’ reputations, but that seems backwards and counterproductive to me.

Leave a Comment