photo by Peter G. Aiken/USA Today Sports
By FRANCO PANIZO
Week 8 of the MLS season had plenty of interesting developments. Both on and off the field.
From commissioner Don Garber talking with certainty about expanding beyond 24 teams to seeing two routs and an eight-goal thriller, Week 8 was plenty eventful. There were also some real standout individual performances, including a two-goal outing from Sporting Kansas City Benny Feilhaber that showed that his international career might not be over just yet.
It was not all good, however. The Philadelphia Union returned to their struggling ways in a lopsided and embarrassing loss to the Columbus Crew that raised concerns over whether players might already be giving up on the season.
Here is what SBI took away from Week 8:
FEILHABER DESERVING OF USMNT CALL-UP
It wasn’t just the two goals – though they certainly helped – but rather a strong overall showing from Benny Feilhaber that helped to earn Sporting Kansas City a dramatic road point in a wild, wild shootout against the Houston Dynamo.
Feilhaber was a man possessed in the thrilling and controversial 4-4 draw at BBVA Compass Stadium on Saturday, actively seeking and getting on the ball and pinging a range of passes to teammates to help jumpstart Kansas City’s attack. He also scored not one but two late equalizers, including a stunning half-volley in the 95th minute, to prevent his side from suffering a loss.
What Feilhaber also demonstrated in the match is that his defensive skills have come a long way. While he was beaten on the set-piece that gave the Dynamo a 4-3 lead, Feilhaber tracked back well and got stuck in in ways that he would not have in the past. Defending was long seen as one of the biggest holes in his game, but the veteran midfielder has developed a more effective two-way style under Sporting KC head coach Peter Vermes that allows him to do both the grunt work without the ball and show off his vision and technique with it.
That’s not exactly a new development. The 30-year-old Feilhaber has been playing like this all season – he also showed this in good spurts in 2014 – and his form is deserving of a U.S. Men’s National Team call-up. Jurgen Klinsmann has not been big on Feilhaber during his term as U.S. coach, selecting him only a few times during his four years in charge. But if Klinsmann wants to really try and implement a more proactive approach then bringing in Feilhaber makes plenty of sense given the way he’s playing right now.
UNION IN A WORLD OF TROUBLE
The much-needed goalkeeper switch provided a good moment of respite, but the Philadelphia Union are still a team that is in big trouble.
The Union endured their latest setback in a season already full of them by getting dismantled, 4-1, on the road by the Columbus Crew. Getting beat by such a wide margin happens over the course of the year to almost every team, but what’s more alarming is how poorly Philadelphia’s players performed.
Jim Curtin’s side had only 38.5 percent of the possession in the match, and were down 3-0 before the halftime whistle even blew. Curtin talked after the match about how some of his players kept grinding through the match while others “bailed out”, which is not exactly a great development when you’re only in the second month of the season.
Look, Curtin deserves some blame for what has gone on this season, but it’s not entirely his fault. He was handicapped by the disastrous and, still to this day, head-scratching addition of Rais Mbolhi and never got true replacements for the solid starting duo of Amobi Okugo and Carlos Valdes.
Curtin has promised to make changes to the lineup next week, but there’s just not a whole lot for him to work with on the squad right now. Throw in the fact that it sounds as if some players are already losing hope, and it’s shaping up to be a terrible season in Philadelphia.
MIAMI AS GOOD AS IN AS MLS SHOWS PATIENCE
Before the round of games began, MLS commissioner Don Garber answered some questions about the state of the league. One of the more revealing things to come out of it all was that MLS is being patient for once when it comes to expansion, particularly with regards to a team in Miami.
Garber was asked about David Beckham’s efforts to bring a team to the South Florida metropolis on Friday, and admitted that finding a suitable plot of land for a soccer-specific stadium has so far been difficult. Garber, however, added that MLS, Beckham and other interested parties have faith that things can be worked. When pushed for a timeline for when a Miami team would join the league, Garber said with a laugh, “by the end of the decade.”
That willingness to wait for things to get resolved is quite the change of pace from MLS’s rapid expansion in recent years. It speaks to the league’s desire to want to bring a franchise back to Miami – especially since Sacramento is making progress in its pursuit of a stadium – and also serves as a reminder that Garber and all league officials always carefully stated that they’d have 24 teams by 2020.
MLS awarded the 21st, 22nd and 23rd spots in a pretty short window as part of its aggressive push to expand, but we are still four-and-a-half years away from the “end of the decade”. Nothing is stopping the league from waiting a bit longer now to iron out the details for a stadium in Miami, which means Beckham and his group are all but guaranteed to lock up that 24th spot at some point.
IMPACT’S EMERGENCY GOALKEEPER LOAN A JOKE IF TRUE
Reports began to surface over the weekend that the Montreal Impact might be able loan in a goalkeeper from another MLS club on an emergency basis. The player would allegedly be available to play in between the pipes in Wednesday’s CONCACAF Champions League second leg final against Club America, an area of concern for the Impact given that starting goalkeeper Evan Bush is suspended due to yellow card accumulation, primary backup Erik Kronberg is ineligible after being cup-tied to Sporting Kansas City, and third-choice netminder Maxime Crepeau is still dealing with an injury.
It’s all one bad joke if true.
MLS wants and needs to have a team that finally wins the CONCACAF Champions League, there’s no doubt about it. The Impact stand a good chance of doing so after grabbing an impressive 1-1 road draw against Club America last week, and returning home to play in front of a big crowd on familiar turf surface.
Still, it is cheap and ridiculous that another unheard of rule could be used to allow the Impact to boost its chances of winning the regional crown. If that’s the case, why not go for the whole shebang and allow Montreal to loan in the MLS All-Stars team? Let them bring over Obafemi Martins, Kaka and Michael Bradley while they’re at it.
It’s understandable that Montreal wants to address its goalkeeping situation ahead of this do-or-die second leg, but adding a starter from another MLS club would be farcical and unsportsmanlike.
If the Impact need a goalkeeper, there are other avenues to get one. There’s the “pool” goalkeeper rule that was made public last year, and also the ability to trade. The latter might not be ideal given that the club only needs a quick-fix, but it’s a more legitimate move than adding another club’s starting goalkeeper for a championship match.
David Accam is a strong MVP candidate, should be not be red-card fouled into a Cook County ambulance. Harry Shipp deserved Jurgens attention.
You don’t need to root for the Union to lose,…they have that under control. Two notes:
1. I feel for Jim Curtain. Not sure it’s his fault.
2. Front office,…owner/operator NS,…has probably lost all credibility with the team after that Algerian GK fiasco. What was he thinking?
While Curtin has been saddled with a whole host of problems by the front office, he has one more to deal with – he’s not ready to coach in MLS.
“I don’t care if we have the ball” is not a tactic which he has been able to master on the field, yet he has built his coaching philosophy around it.
1. Curtin is a good guy. He’s a Philly guy. I love his honesty and the fact that he doesn’t make excuses. He’s been dealt a sh*tty hand and asked to try and play it with one hand tied behind his back. I think everyone respects him for that and ultimately, I think most people feel like the guy is going to be a good coach in this league. But right now, he’s in over his head and this is not the organization nor the situation to allow him to develop.
2. Sak was thinking that he could use M’Bolhi as a showpiece to go out and tell the fans “Look! Look at what I brought you! You say we act like a third rate club and never spend money on big names or make big signings, well look what I did!” It didn’t matter that signing M’Bolhi was like bringing bags of sand to the beach, when what you really needed was a comfortable chair and a cooler of beer. He was a big(ish) name coming off a big performance in a major tournament, and apparently Sak thought that would be enough.
I’m not sure I want to imagine what that locker room is like right now. While his team is falling apart at the seems, Sakeiwicz is over in England watching Bournemouth get promoted. Curtin is trying to figure out how not to lose this team and Andrew Wenger is trying to remember how to play soccer. Fernando Aristegueita is wondering what the hell he did to deserve this junk show. What it comes down to though is that when things go south, you ultimately end up playing for the guys next to you. That didn’t happen on Saturday in Columbus, and whether or not it happens this Saturday against Toronto will go a long, long way in showing just where this team is going.
I repeat, is it too early to start rooting for the Union to lose so that there will be a management shakeup?
Has anyone noticed the parallels between NYCFC and Chivas USA RIP?
1. Second team in a city.
2. Ownership knock-off of a big club in another country.
3. Renting a venue with no stadium of their own.
4. Over-hyped rivalry.
Perhaps MLS has some contractual obligations that make it preferable for them to wait on Beckham.
Meanwhile Sacramento has ownership every bit as impressive as NYCFC, a stadium, fanbase, etc. The Golden State triumvirate with SJ and LA mirrors the Cascadia rivalry, arguably the most successful in MLS.
Not sure what has been said in the TV contract talks, or ownership meetings, but Sacramento makes way more sense to me than Miami, LAFC, or NYCFC.
“1. Second team in a city.”
Bc THAT won’t EVER work… (NYJ/NYG, LAD/LAA, SFG/OA, LAL/LAC…..)
“2. Ownership knock-off of a big club in another country.”
Pretty sure Man City is a step up from Chivas (MEX)….
“3. Renting a venue with no stadium of their own.”
#WhiteGirlProblems
“4. Over-hyped rivalry.”
Sure…
Cantamount, while you are completely correct with your observations regarding the NYC Farm Club, give it time. Sacramento did not get David Villa to come to MLS, but the farm club did. That is the only thing I can say in their defense (could care less about Lampard). As a fan of MLS I am very grateful that I get to see David Villa playing in the league
Something doesn’t make sense in the Miami situation.
They will wait indefinitely for Miami to get a team at $20 million ( not sure that is the exact number, but huge discount ), when so many other cities are lining up for a team in MLS?
Why? Miami failed once
Why? Miami is failing again, no stadium still
Why? Would the owners want this in the first place, you would think they would say, “times up” and lets collect $60-80 million more.
I don’t get it. I can’t have the full story.
I don’t believe we’re missing any portion of the story.
Don refuses to give up on Miami with Beckham despite better prospects being available with actual stadiums/stadium plans and a credible fan base. Look no further than the quagmire NYCFC will become when no stadium is built for over a decade, if even then (and when/if it does happen, it’ll be well outside the actual city).
FEILHABER DESERVING OF USMNT CALL-UP
this x100
he has deserved this 41 times already….
Benny should get goal of the week for that strike to tie the match. The instant I saw the ball going to him I said it was going in the net, and I bet I’m not the only one. That is why he should be playing for the US. But JK seems to favor “nasty” athletes, unproven Adu-type prodigies, and random players over technique and brains.
Jazz hands!
Keep on prancin’
https://s.yimg.com/cd/resizer/original/KhB2DO–leUX9SALkqIiQtwaM6s.gif
The photos SBI utilize are hilarious.
I’ve been coming to this site for years, and its one of my top reasons why. Keep it up, fellas! I know it’d be easy to just slap up the first decent looking photo, but I appreciate that you guys look extra for the funny ones.